1878-P VAM-84 Washed Out L, Broken D

Discovered by Leroy Van Allen, December 1965.

84 II/I 12 - B1e (Washed Out L, Broken D) (180) I-3 R-4
Obverse II/I 12- Slightly doubled LIBERTY shifted left, with surface around L flat and detail not brought out. Missing nostril. Doubled E PLURB and S in E PLURIBUS. Doubled 1-4, 6 & 7 left stars and all right stars. Slanted dash below left 8 with die chip at top left inside of upper loop on some specimens.
Key identifier- Dash below left 8.
Reverse B1e- D of DOLLAR broken at bottom with just two lines remaining. Die chip on eagle's right wing, sixth feather down and also next to body. Die over polished with blank areas in eagle's left wing and tail feathers.

Comments:
1- VAM-84 is one of only two B1 reverse varieties with both unique obverse and reverse. The other is VAM-83.
2- The VAM book calls this variety Washed-out L and that is indeed a pick up point for this as is the long dash under the first 8 of the date. The overpolished nostril would round those out and make for a quick attribution for a heads-up viewing in a dealer's case.
3- The overpolished nostril would round those out and make for a quick attribution for a heads-up viewing in a dealer's case.
4- EDS of VAM-84A.
5- We always look at the reverse first when attributing 1878 varieties. In this case, one would quickly see the long nock (arrow shaft end) and the absence of traces of an A reverse (7/8 TF) generally looking under the olive on the branch and at the legs (not doubled for B1 reverses).

LVA Plate Photos:
1878-P_VAM-84_PLATE_1_PART._BROKEN_D_12_OCT_2010.jpg1878-P_VAM-84_PLATE_2_OVER_POLISHED_LEAF_AND_L_12_OCT_2010.jpg1878-P_VAM-84_PLATE_3_DASH_BELOW_8_12_OCT_2010.jpg

Additional photos:
Washed out L, Lightly doubled R I B
1878-P_VAM-84_RIB_LIBERTY_VW_15_OCT_2010.jpg

The broken bottom of the D gives this variety away immediately. All that is left there are two thin lines at the base.
1878-P_VAM-84_BROKEN_D_VW_15_2010.jpg

Notice the line under the 8 in the date:
1878-P_VAM-84_FULL_DATE_VW_15_OCT_2010.jpg

And the washed out nostril:
1878-P_VAM-84_MISSING_NOSTRIL_VAM-84_15_OCT_2010.jpg

There is also doubling of the obverse features in several locations:
1878-P_VAM-84_DOUBLED_STAR_E_VW_15_OCT_2010.jpg

Doubled Liberty
1878-P_VAM-84_BE_OF_LIBERTY_VW_15_OCT_2010.jpg

die chip on the eagle's right wing 6th feather up from the bottom
1878-P_VAM-84_DIE_CHIP_WING_VW_15_OCT_2010.jpg

and one of the many doubled stars.
1878-P_VAM-84_VW_STAR_X_15_OCT_2010.jpg

Full Coin Copyrighted© VAM-84 Images© on loan to VAMworld courtesy SB_18_logo.png® ATTRIBUTED BY Ron Hagler
1878_RonH_VAM-84_OBV_06042012SB.jpg
1878_RonH_VAM-84_REV_06042012SB.jpg

Full Coin Copyrighted© VAM- Images on loan to VAMworld courtesy ©Heritage Auctions ATTRIBUTED BY Ron Hagler

High Resolution Heritage Photographs used in their catalogs. Also known as "plate photo".
1878_RonH_VAM-84_OBV_PLATE_12202012.jpg
1878_RonH_VAM-84_REV_PLATE_12202012.jpg

From Heritage's auction archives another here here



Price History:

1878-P VAM-84 PCGS MS65 eBay $195.55 1/01/2010

1878-P VAM-84 PCGS MS62 eBay $62.99 10/04/09
1878-P VAM-84 NGC MS62 $86.50 VAMquest 3/07



Condition Census: PCGS MS 63

PCGS MS 64 DMPL
PCGS MS 63 DMPL (3)
PCGS MS 65
Top